Permanent Magnets: Quick Guide to Pros, Cons & Selection
Permanent magnets power modern tech but vary wildly in performance. Here’s a concise breakdown of key materials and how to choose them.
Key Metrics
- Energy (BHmax): Magnetic strength per volume.
- Coercivity (Hc): Resistance to demagnetization.
- Temperature Limit: Maximum operating heat.
- Cost: Material + processing expenses.
4 Major Types Compared
Material | Pros | Cons | Best For |
---|
Neodymium (NdFeB) | Strongest (50+ MGOe), compact, cost-efficient | Overheats (>200°C), corrodes easily, rare-earth dependent | EVs, drones, high-performance motors |
Ferrite | Cheap, heat-resistant (450°C), corrosion-proof | Weak (4 MGOe), bulky, fails below -40°C | Appliances, speakers, separators |
Samarium Cobalt (SmCo) | Handles heat (350°C), radiation-proof, no coating needed | Expensive (cobalt), moderate strength (30 MGOe) | Satellites, oil drilling, military |
Alnico | Stable from -60°C to 550°C, high remanence | Easily demagnetized, weak (8 MGOe), outdated | Sensors, vintage electronics |
How to Choose in 3 Steps
Temperature:
- Extreme heat (>300°C) → SmCo
- Normal temps → NdFeB or Ferrite
Budget:
- Lowest cost → Ferrite
- Best performance → NdFeB
Environment:
- Harsh (corrosion/radiation) → SmCo
- Basic → Ferrite or NdFeB
Future Innovations
Got a project? Share your specs below for tailored advice!